Jack Salmon recently ranked the major sources of state and local tax revenue according to two sensible criteria: economic growth and revenue volatility. Among the taxes examined as major revenue sources, property taxes impose the least economic distortion and are the least volatile. They stand out as a reliable source of government revenue.
Even a relatively efficient tax, however, can expand government’s fiscal capacity if the institutions governing revenue, spending and borrowing are left unchecked. Preventing abuse of the least bad tax, therefore, requires limits on both revenue and spending.
Why Property Taxes Have Low Revenue Volatility
Using Census Bureau data going back to 2005, Salmon finds that personal income tax revenue has a volatility score of 9.7 compared with 4.6 for sales tax revenue and 25.8 for corporate income tax revenue. Property tax revenue, with a score of 4.3, is the least volatile of the major state and local revenue sources. Corporate income tax revenue was more than five times as volatile as sales tax revenue, while individual income tax revenue was more than twice as volatile.
Revenue volatility partly reflects how readily taxpayers can change their behavior. In economics, elasticity measures how much behavior changes when a price changes. The more substantial the behavioral change, the greater the elasticity of demand with respect to price.
The same intuition helps explain tax base elasticity, which describes how much taxpayers change their behavior when a tax changes. A relatively elastic tax base gives taxpayers more ways to reduce the amount subject to a tax when the tax burden rises. Businesses may change investment or production decisions, consumers can alter purchases, and workers or firms can eventually relocate. A relatively inelastic tax base offers fewer ways to respond. Furthermore, tax base elasticity can be greater over longer periods because households and businesses have more time to adjust where they live and work (students of economics will recognize this as the second law of demand).
Because of their low volatility, property taxes present taxpayers with fewer opportunities to adjust. Land can’t cross a state line when property tax burdens increase through higher rates or assessments. A homeowner cannot relocate a house to the next county. Real estate is observable, assessable and difficult to conceal. This relatively low elasticity helps explain both why property taxation creates fewer behavioral responses than other taxes and why its revenue is unusually dependable.
That same relatively lower elasticity also helps explain why governments and their creditors value property taxes so highly.
The municipal bond market provides an especially useful illustration. Property taxes are commonly associated with local general obligation finance, and investors place value on their stability. Property taxes are often cited as the largest and most stable source of local government revenue, and they are also credited as a major factor influencing municipal credit quality and lower borrowing costs. Both investors and credit rating agencies warn that eliminating or substantially weakening property taxes could increase revenue volatility and cause a reassessment of municipal credit risk.
From the taxpayer’s perspective, those same characteristics make property taxes an unusually powerful instrument for fiscal extraction because taxpayers have fewer opportunities to escape a larger fiscal claim. The revenue source that appears the most efficient under a fixed-revenue assumption may also give a revenue-seeking government considerable capacity to tax and borrow.
The Lesson: Starve the Beast of Responsibility First, Then Revenue
This is where public choice theory, which assumes that those in politics act in their rational self-interest and respond to incentives in the same way they do outside of politics, adds something to Salmon’s ranking. In “The Power to Tax,” Geoffrey Brennan and James Buchanan challenged the conventional assumption that policymakers begin with a fixed revenue requirement and merely choose the least costly way to meet it. Their “revenue-maximizing Leviathan” model is designed to ask how tax rules themselves affect government’s capacity and incentives to raise revenue. Different fiscal institutions can affect how much revenue government seeks in the first place.
The lesson of “revenue-maximizing Leviathan” is that fiscal rules should be designed with the possibility of revenue-seeking behavior in mind. A rule that constrains one tax without reducing spending, borrowing or alternative revenues may end up redirecting fiscal activity elsewhere.
That last point is why Brennan and Buchanan made an important distinction between the choices made within rules and choices about the rules themselves. If we want to stop government from abusing property taxes durably, the argument must extend beyond property tax rates to the rules governing government’s responsibilities and spending.
To this end, priority-based budgeting—a paradigm forged by Washington Governor Gary Locke, operationalized for cities by Chris Fabian, and made workable for states by Jonathan Williams and ALEC—replaces the standard incremental budgeting system—adjusting previous budget amounts slightly for the new fiscal period—with budgeting based on how proposed spending aligns with the proper role of government. To achieve this, priority-based budgeting poses five key budget questions: What is the proper role of government? What are the essential services the government must provide to fulfill its purpose? How will we know if the government is doing a good job? What should it cost? When cuts must be made, how will they be properly prioritized?
This process takes more careful consideration than the standard process, but it can generate savings by removing policies that do not serve the core functions of government. It is most successful if it treats government as a single entity and does not exclude agencies or enterprises from the priority-based budget process.
If government has effective limits on the role it plays in society, limiting its ability to exploit an immobile tax base is much easier than simply capping tax rates.
How To Stop the Abuse of the Least Bad Tax
Fortunately, there is no shortage of options available to limit property taxes, spending and scope of government.
One option is Utah’s Truth in Taxation system, which prevents increases in assessed values from automatically producing equivalent increases in property tax revenue from existing property. A cap on the nominal tax rate alone cannot accomplish this. For example, a home assessed at $350,000 will have a tax bill of $3,500 in a state with a 1% property tax rate. If the home’s assessed value increases to $400,000 next year, the property tax bill becomes $4,000. The homeowner sees a $500 tax increase even though the tax rate remained at 1%.
Instead, Utah’s system calculates a “certified tax rate” designed to generate roughly the same property tax revenue as the previous year with adjustments for new growth. If the value of existing property rises, the certified rate generally falls.
Local governments remain free to collect more, but they must be subject to the Truth in Taxation process. Before adopting a rate above the certified rate, the taxing entity advertises the proposed increase, holds a public hearing and then takes a publicly recorded vote. This allows taxpayers to see that the government is choosing to collect more money rather than sneaking increases through assessment values.
The transparency that comes from Truth in Taxation addresses the revenue side of the problem, but not the underlying demand for spending. Broader revenue and spending limits would complement transparency with voter approval required above the ceiling. Property tax rates could then fall when assessment growth exceeds the permitted levy.
Any rule’s perimeter should also be broad enough to capture special districts, public authorities and tax-supported debt so that fiscal activity does not simply migrate outside the constraint. To ensure that the fiscal rules remain durable, government’s spending commitments must be constantly reassessed.
Conclusion
Salmon’s ranking captures an important truth: Property taxes can raise relatively stable revenue while producing fewer economic distortions than many alternatives. The same immobility that makes the property tax base attractive to economists, however, also makes it dependable to municipal bond investors and difficult for taxpayers to escape.
The answer is to place rules around the fiscal capacity that property taxes create. The least bad tax may still be the easiest to abuse. Keeping it the least bad requires constraining how government raises money and how much government promises to spend.
Thomas Savidge is a research fellow at the American Institute for Economic Research. Follow on X: @thomas_savidge.



In my opinion, property taxes should be abolished because property taxes are an unconstitutional wealth tax on unrealized gains. Property/wealth taxes are based on the current value of your home (an unrealized gain) rather than based on the cost of the purchase of your home. As home values increase then property taxes increase which have made homeownership unaffordable.
We do not tax the unrealized gains on stocks, gold, bitcoin, vintage cars, art, etc. We tax those items on their gains when they are sold. So, why don’t we apply the same law/rules for homes/property.
https://x.com/MirthIsland/status/2076992002990944335
No one should lose a $200,000 home over a $2,000 property tax bill.
https://x.com/JohnStossel/status/2031745459644207457
No one should lose a $300,000 home because they owed $22,000 in property taxes.
(No one should lose their home because they cannot afford to pay their property taxes. Property taxes are close to theft. The idea that the government can constantly escalate the cost of owning your property it's pernicious.)
Instead of property taxes all households (renters, owners, etc.) should pay a monthly or annual fee to fund essential services in their communities. If everyone paid this fee then the cost per household to fund essential services would be lower for everyone.
Property taxes are used to pay for schools, fire, police, roads, (essential services), which everyone benefits from, so why are only property owners paying taxes to fund the fire, police, schools, etc, which all of us use and need?
Would a fairer tax (and to make sure everyone is paying for essential services), be to place a fee as a separate line item on a water, electricity, or garbage bill, or annually on tax returns? The fee would be unrelated to the utility bill or tax return, but it would be a convenient way for the government to collect the fees necessary to fund local and state governments. No one would have their water, electricity, garbage, etc. shut off or their home confiscated because they did not pay the fees to fund the government. The fines and penalties for nonpayment of the fees for essential services would be enforced by state and local boards with penalties and interest.
This fee would replace property taxes.
Homeowners should not be the only ones funding the cost of essential services (fire, police, schools, etc.) nor should property taxes go up every year based on the value of your home, and homeowners should not lose their home for nonpayment of property taxes. (If you pay property taxes based on the increased value of your home then why are you required to pay capital gains taxes based on the increased value of your home when you sell your home? Isn't this double taxation even if it is state vs federal taxes? At the very least homeowners should be able to deduct the property taxes they have paid from their capital gains taxes.)
Could a thorough audit be carried out on state and local governments every three years, so taxpayers know exactly what they are paying for and to get rid of waste including high salaries and unnecessary positions/jobs, projects, etc? Also, to keep taxes as low as possible all government workers should have a 401k/403b (defined contribution) plans. No more taxpayer funded pensions. (Taxpayers should not have to fund their own retirement and then pay for government workers' retirement too.)
Could the blockchain be used to record every transaction by government so we know exactly where our tax dollars are going and how our money is being spent?
Once taxpayers know the cost/size of the government they want, then taxpayers can decide what they want to fund.
An auditor would calculate the fees necessary to fund the government. (Cost of government divided by the number of households in the area = fee per household attached to a utility bill or tax return to fund the government.)
Fees could be attached to water bills to cover the cost of funding the government and everyone would be required to pay the fee including homeowners, renters, businesses, charities, etc., since everyone uses essential services. The fees would be a separate line item on the monthly water bill or on their income taxes, so everyone would know what they were/are contributing to fund/pay for their government.
People who buy bottled water and/or who have water delivered to their homes and businesses would also pay a fee on the bottled or delivered water to fund the government.
I picked water bills instead of electric or garbage bills because everyone needs water and water bills are a convenient option to add a fee to, since almost every household and business has a water bill including universities, churches, other nonprofits who currently do not pay property taxes but they benefit from essential services. (And, universities and churches often own a lot of real estate plus they tend to have huge endowments/savings.)
My main point is that everyone needs and uses essential services (schools, roads, fire, police, etc.), so why are only property owners paying taxes to support these services? (Should we deny essential services to people who do not pay for them via property taxes?)
The fee would help everyone contribute to paying for schools, fire, police, roads, etc., and since every household would be contributing the tax burden would be lighter for everyone. By including the fee to fund government on homeowners' monthly water bill or annual tax returns people would be more aware of the cost of government and hopefully this will encourage more people to be involved.
Some of the ways to replace revenue if we eliminate unconstitutional property/wealth taxes
• Government pensions should be converted from defined benefit to defined contribution (401k type)
• Government pensions should also follow Social Security rules and laws regarding retirement - cap the maximum annual amount a retiree can receive; and full retirement should be the same as Social Security and at least age 67, etc. (Tax payers should not have to fund their own retirement and then have to pay high taxes, especially property taxes, to fund the pensions of government employees.)
• Implement a state capital gains tax and allow the deduction of state capital gains taxes from the amount you owe in federal capital gains taxes when you sell your home. Also, add interest paid to the basis on a home to help reduce capital gains taxes. (Adding interest to the basis of the home would help reflect the true cost of a home.)
• If we continue to allow unconstitutional property/wealth taxes then they should be added to the basis of the home too, to help reduce capital gains taxes when your home is sold.
• Universities, churches, other nonprofits do not currently pay property taxes and they often own a lot of real estate plus they often have huge endowments/savings. Why should nonprofits be exempt from paying property taxes especially when we do not exempt our elderly or young people from paying property taxes?
• At the very least we should eliminate the tax deduction for donations. A gift is a gift and you should not expect anything (a deduction) in return for your donation/gift. The revenue the federal government gains by eliminating the deduction for nonprofits could be given to states to help replace the loss in revenue from the elimination of unconstitutional property taxes.
• Repurpose foreign aid to states to help replace any loss in revenue from eliminating property taxes.
• And, if we enforced our immigration laws there would be less pressure to increase the size of our government (schools, hospitals, prisons, roads, etc.) and there would be less upward pressure on home prices and thus less pressure to increase property taxes.
The "volatility of the income tax is a feature, not a bug.
What would make property taxes least bad (low DWL), demands that they be constantly adjusted to the market value of the property, which not neessarily stable. In practice they are more shot through with exemptions, different rates for diffeent classes of property, and backward-looking valuations, that sales taxes are pobably less bad.